Non-contact blow thermoforming: optical excellence for demanding industries
|
Thermoforming is suitable for large parts and small production runs.
|
Your plastic part has been designed, and three processes seem possible. A wrong choice will cost you in terms of tooling and lead times.
A steel injection mould for just a few dozen parts will not pay for itself. Conversely, a thermoforming mould used for thousands of parts per year drives up the cost of each part. In both cases, the tooling must be remade and you’ll have to wait for weeks.
Here is a five-question guide to help you choose between thermoforming, RIM injection moulding and conventional injection moulding. It is based on our experience as a manufacturer specialising in small and medium-sized production runs.
Thermoforming, RIM injection moulding, conventional injection moulding: the three processes at a glance
Each process shapes the material in its own way and determines the cost, precision and size of the parts.
Thermoforming
Thermoforming transforms a heated plastic sheet into a part using a single-sided mould. The softened sheet is pressed onto the mould using suction or pressure, then trimmed after cooling. The mould, made of resin or aluminium, remains affordable.
RIM injection moulding
RIM injection moulding produces polyurethane parts using low pressure. A polyol and an isocyanate – two liquid components – are injected into a closed mould where they cure. This low pressure allows the use of an aluminium mould rather than a steel one.
Conventional injection moulding
Conventional injection moulding melts plastic pellets and injects them at very high pressure into a steel mould. The mould is expensive, but the cycles are short: the higher the volume, the lower the price per part.
The 5 questions to help you choose your process
Five questions are all it takes to choose the process best suited to your needs. Answer in order: the production volume often rules out an option right from the start.
1. What is the annual production volume?
For volumes below several thousand parts per year, consider thermoforming or RIM injection moulding. Above this threshold, conventional injection moulding recoups the cost of the steel mould. The exact threshold is calculated based on the cost of the mould, the material and the size of the part. Our design office will work out the figures for your project.
2. What is the part size?
The larger the part, the more thermoforming and RIM injection moulding are recommended. Thermoforming can produce parts several metres in size with reasonable tooling, whilst RIM injection moulding can handle dimensions of up to 1,200 × 1,200 mm and beyond. Conventional injection moulding requires a press and a mould to the scale of the part, which drives up the cost.
3. What is the geometry?
Ribs, clips and mounting bosses point towards RIM or conventional injection moulding. Thermoforming does not mould these directly; they are added afterwards by gluing, welding or mechanical assembly. RIM integrates them with variable thicknesses and overmoulded metal inserts.
4. What level of precision and surface finish?
Conventional injection moulding offers the highest precision. In thermoforming, industry tolerances range from ±0.25 to ±1.5 mm depending on the part’s size, compared with a few hundredths of a millimetre in high-precision injection moulding.
Thermoforming has a solution: 3- and 5-axis CNC machining can adjust critical dimensions after forming. The surface finish, meanwhile, depends on the mould: polished for a glossy part, sandblasted for a matt or textured finish.
5. What is the tooling budget and lead time?
Thermoforming and RIM require the most cost-effective and quickest-to-produce tooling. Their resin or aluminium moulds can be easily modified, whereas a steel injection mould is significantly more expensive, as is any modification to it.
Is your product still in the testing phase? Choose thermoforming or RIM: you can change a dimension without having to remake the entire mould.
| Criterion | Thermoforming | RIM injection moulding | Conventional injection moulding |
| Annual volume | Tens to small batches | Small to medium batches | Several thousand parts |
| Size | Up to several metres | 1,200 × 1,200 mm and above | Compact parts |
| Geometry | Simple to moderate | Complex, ribs, inserts | Maximum complexity |
| Accuracy | ±0.25 to ±1.5 mm | Close to that of injection moulding | Very high |
| Moulding tooling | Resin or aluminium | Aluminium or resin | Steel, expensive |
| Need a quote? Send your specifications to the design office: they will advise you on the most cost-effective process for your production volumes. |
RIM injection moulding: the third option for large parts in small and medium-volume production runs
RIM injection moulding bridges the gap between thermoforming and conventional injection moulding: a moulded part, with affordable tooling. An aluminium mould costs significantly less than a steel mould, making the process cost-effective from as few as a few dozen parts.
Polyurethane offers properties similar to those of ABS or polycarbonate: impact resistance, rigidity and dimensional stability. UL94 V0 flame-retardant formulations are available for regulated applications.
Typical applications: machine covers, fairings for specialised vehicles, medical and laboratory housings. The surfaces, whether smooth or textured, can be painted or screen-printed in our finishing workshop.
| Discover our RIM injection moulding service |
What thermoforming cannot do, and how to compensate for this
Thermoforming thins the material at the corners and requires trimming. A stretched sheet loses thickness where it is stretched the most, particularly in deep cavities. Bubble forming and pressure thermoforming distribute the thickness more evenly.
After forming, the part retains excess material. Our 3- and 5-axis machining centres trim it, drill openings and mill the assembly interfaces.
Combining thermoforming and machining produces complex parts at a cost that neither process could achieve on its own.
| See our range of plastic thermoforming |
When should you switch to conventional injection moulding? (and why we don’t offer it)
Switch to conventional injection moulding as soon as your production volume reaches several thousand parts per year. At this level, the steel mould pays for itself and each short cycle reduces the unit cost. Very tight tolerances or integrated clips and ribs also make it necessary.
Plastisart does not offer conventional injection moulding, and we prefer to let you know this upfront. We’ll guide you towards the process best suited to your part, even if it’s outside our workshop.
A part initially produced using thermoforming or RIM can switch to injection moulding as its market grows. Our design office will advise you on the right time to make the switch.
How does Plastisart choose the process with you?
We choose the process with you before proceeding with tooling. Our design office is integrated into our workshops, and our technicians manufacture the mould in-house. Lead times remain short, and you have a single point of contact.
| Planning a plastic part project? Request a quote: we’ll assess feasibility and identify the most suitable process. |
Thermoforming or plastic injection moulding: questions manufacturers ask
Which process is the most cost-effective for small batches?
Thermoforming is generally more cost-effective, thanks to its single-sided moulds made from resin or aluminium. RIM injection moulding is the preferred choice for complex parts. Our design office compares the two based on your drawings.
What is the difference between RIM injection moulding and conventional injection moulding?
RIM involves injecting two reactive liquids at low pressure into an aluminium mould. Conventional injection moulding involves injecting molten plastic at very high pressure into a steel mould. RIM is cheaper in terms of tooling costs and per part for large production runs.
What are the tolerances in thermoforming?
Allow for ±0.25 to ±1.5 mm depending on the part’s size. Critical dimensions are re-machined after forming.
Can we switch from thermoforming to injection moulding later on?
Yes, when production volumes increase. The part must then be redesigned for the new process: draft angles, uniform wall thicknesses, integrated ribs.
In summary
Thermoforming for large parts and small production runs, RIM for large technical parts, and conventional injection moulding for production runs of several thousand parts per year. Send us your specifications for the manufacture of bespoke plastic parts: we’ll validate the process before any investment in tooling is made.
| See our bespoke plastic parts manufacturing service |